公共行政學(xué)研究論文在二十世紀(jì)九十年代，新的管理見解對組織機(jī)構(gòu)應(yīng)當(dāng)如何被管理、下屬應(yīng)當(dāng)如何被指導(dǎo)、政府項(xiàng)目的消費(fèi)者應(yīng)當(dāng)如何被對待等問題有重大影響。1992年，巴澤勒(MichaelBarzelay)與阿摩亞尼(BabakArmajani)發(fā)表突破官僚制：政府管理的新視野。該書基于在明尼蘇達(dá)州的革新實(shí)驗(yàn)，即通過強(qiáng)調(diào)顧客服務(wù)、給雇員授權(quán)、有選擇性的競爭和減少行政規(guī)章制度而改變公共項(xiàng)目。兩位作者認(rèn)為，政府不應(yīng)當(dāng)是官僚型、規(guī)章制度約束、強(qiáng)調(diào)控制和沒有靈活性，他們向韋伯型的傳統(tǒng)組織結(jié)構(gòu)和運(yùn)作機(jī)理提出了挑戰(zhàn)。 如果說巴澤勒與阿摩亞尼對傳統(tǒng)管理的批評代表著對管理體制改革的呼吁，那么，質(zhì)量管理運(yùn)動(dòng)則提供了內(nèi)在改革的動(dòng)力。最初的全方位質(zhì)量管理(TotalQualityManagement-TQM)源于私有企業(yè)部門，但公共生產(chǎn)力與管理評論(PublicProductivityandManagementReview-PPMR)在過去二十多年的努力也使我們認(rèn)識(shí)到TQM對于公共部門機(jī)構(gòu)業(yè)績與質(zhì)量改善的重要性。PPMR提供了豐富的案例以及公共機(jī)構(gòu)如何改善、引入、調(diào)整并保持連續(xù)的質(zhì)量改進(jìn)的理論性評論。PPMR雜志的資深主編霍哲(MarcHolzer)教授在生產(chǎn)力與質(zhì)量管理(ProductivityandQualityManagement)(1995)一文中評論了質(zhì)量管理以及質(zhì)量管理對于公共部門管理的啟迪。很明顯，九十年代的TQM已經(jīng)成為公共管理的基本方法。TQM的核心特征是統(tǒng)計(jì)評估、顧客信息反饋、雇員參與質(zhì)量改善、供應(yīng)商合作。這些TQM的手段和方法已經(jīng)成為當(dāng)今多數(shù)經(jīng)理的“管理常識(shí)”。不少人認(rèn)為，質(zhì)量管理不僅適用于制造業(yè)，而且更適合服務(wù)部門。質(zhì)量管理已成為公共管理的部分基礎(chǔ)。 公共政策與分析的迅猛發(fā)展 首先，許多公共事務(wù)學(xué)院在加州大學(xué)伯克利分校的帶領(lǐng)下紛紛部分或全部轉(zhuǎn)向公共政策，盡管錫拉丘茲大學(xué)麥克斯韋爾學(xué)院及南加州大學(xué)仍然高舉公共行政大旗，亦增添了政策研究方向。最初的政策研究包括政策形成理論、政策分析技術(shù)、政策執(zhí)行、政策計(jì)劃和政策評估等，重心開始轉(zhuǎn)向政策形成（政策制定）和政策內(nèi)容（政策分析）。其次，一批新成立的雜志為政策研究增添了活力。如政策分析和管理雜志(JournalofPolicyAnalysisandManagement)、政策研究雜志(PolicyStudiesJournal)、政策研究評論(PolicyStudiesReview)以及政策科學(xué)(PolicySciences)等。最后，進(jìn)入二十世紀(jì)九十年代，政策科學(xué)已經(jīng)成為一門獨(dú)立的研究領(lǐng)域，大有與公共行政學(xué)分庭抗禮之勢。政策分析融入經(jīng)濟(jì)學(xué)、政治學(xué)、公共財(cái)政、系統(tǒng)理論以及其它社會(huì)科學(xué)學(xué)科，以研究公共政策如何形成和如何完善政府項(xiàng)目。 結(jié)束語：政府改革永恒的主題 歸納起來，萊特(PaulC.Light)在改革的浪潮：改善政府工作，1945-1995(1997)一書中，總結(jié)了改革的四大浪潮：1.科學(xué)管理，強(qiáng)調(diào)嚴(yán)格的等級制、分工、清楚的命令鏈；2.向浪費(fèi)宣戰(zhàn)，重點(diǎn)是監(jiān)督員、審計(jì)員、核對員、評審員；3.警惕的眼睛，倡導(dǎo)陽光、公開性、透明度；4.解放管理，呼吁讓管理者去管理。 財(cái)政緊縮和業(yè)績改善只是政府面臨的諸多壓力的一部分。進(jìn)入二十世紀(jì)，公眾對政府的信心在下降，這或許是政治家們不得不反復(fù)進(jìn)行政府改革的主要原因?？肆诸D總統(tǒng)上任3個(gè)月就宣布了他的改革計(jì)劃，于1993年成立了由副總統(tǒng)戈?duì)枓鞄浀摹懊绹鴺I(yè)績評論委員會(huì)”(NPR)。當(dāng)我們回眸二十世紀(jì)，就不難發(fā)現(xiàn)無論是1910,1937,1949,1972,1982，還是1993的政府改革，都有一個(gè)共同的假設(shè)：即美國聯(lián)邦政府的機(jī)能失調(diào)、組織渙散、業(yè)績平平不能讓公眾滿意。 1883年彭德爾頓法案創(chuàng)立了美國公務(wù)員委員會(huì)，公務(wù)員制度的建立以及城市膨脹的需求催生了美國的公共行政學(xué)。1887年，威爾遜提出了創(chuàng)立獨(dú)立的行政學(xué)學(xué)科的構(gòu)想。隨后，古德諾于1900年談到行政學(xué)與政治學(xué)的分離。再之后，泰勒開始了科學(xué)管理的研究。30年代的羅斯福新政，尤其是布郎諾報(bào)告直接誘發(fā)了政府部門的膨脹和改革1993年至2000年執(zhí)政的克林頓仍舊在重塑政府。一次次改革，一次次不同的主題，變化的是內(nèi)容，不變的是要改變、要改革的努力。 改革政府并非是美國的獨(dú)有現(xiàn)象。無論是東方還是西方，無論是北半球還是南半球，無論是工業(yè)發(fā)達(dá)國家、發(fā)展中國家還是前蘇聯(lián)或東歐轉(zhuǎn)軌國家，在二十世紀(jì)末都洶涌著改革的浪潮。無論是源于財(cái)政危機(jī)、管理危機(jī)或是信仰危機(jī)，出路只有一條，那就是不斷的改革。改革政府不僅是我們時(shí)代的主旋律，也必將是未來政府所要面臨的長期挑戰(zhàn)。 作者感謝下列教授在美國公共行政學(xué)百年回顧及相關(guān)課程所給予筆者的指導(dǎo)和幫助：霍哲教授(MarcHolzer)、達(dá)布里克教授(MelvinDubnick)、威克（女）教授(MarciaWhicker)、梅戈特（女）教授(AstridMerget)、英格拉姆（女）教授(PatriciaIngraham)、布雷思萊德教授(StuartBretchneider)、斯特勞思曼教授(JeffreyStraussman)。 1張夢中美國聯(lián)邦政府改革剖析J中國行政管理，1999,6. 2Acker,Joan.”GenderingOrganizationalTheory”inGenderingOrganizationalAnalysis,ed.A.J.MillsandP.Tancred.NewburyPark:Sage,1992. 3Allison,G.T.EssenceofDecision:ExplainingtheCubanMissileCrisis.Boston:Little,BrownandCompany.1971. 4Appleby,Paul.BigDemocracy.NewYork:Knopf,1945. 5Argyris,Chris.PersonalityandOrganization.NewYork:Harper,1957. 6Arrow,KennethJ.SocialChoiceandIndividualValues.NewYork:JohnWiley&Sons,1951. 7Barnard,Chester”InformalOrganizationsandTheirRelationstoFormalOrganizations”SeeShafritz,JayM.&Hyde,AlbertCed.ClassicsofPublicAdministration4thed.pp95-99. 8BarnardCI.TheFunctionsoftheExecutive.Cambridge,MA:HarvardUniversityPress,1938 9Barzelay,Michael&Armajani,Babak.BreakingThroughBureaucracy:NewVisionforManaginginGovernment.1992. 10Behn,RD,ed.Asymposium:PolicyAnalysisinGovernment:alterativesto”MuddlingThrough.”PublicAdministrationReview40:603-626,1980. 11BoyerMC.DreamingtheRationalCity:TheMythofAmericanCityPlanning.Cambridge,MA:MITPress,1983. 12BrownellBA&StickleW.BossesandReformers:UrbanPoliticsinAmerica,1880-1920.Boston:HoughtonMifflin,1973; 13BrownlowL,Merriam,C.E.&GulickL.ReportofthePresidentsCommitteeonAdministrativeManagement1937.SeeShafritz,JayM.&Hyde,AlbertCed.ClassicsofPublicAdministration4thed.pp90-94. 14Buchanan,JamesM.&Tullock,Gordon.TheCalculusofConsent:LogicalfoundationsofConstitutionalDemocracy.AnnArbor:TheUniversityofMichiganPress,1962. 15Caiden,Naomi.”PublicBudgetingamidUncertaintyandInstability”PublicBudgetingandFinance,1981 16GallowAB,ed.TheCityBossesinAmerica:AnInterpretativeReader.NewYork:OxfordUniversityPress,1976. 17ChandlerAD,Jr.TheVisibleHand:TheManagerialRevolutioninAmericanBusiness.Cambridge,MA:HarvardUniversityPress,1984. 18ChildsRS.CivilVictories:TheStoryofanUnfinishedRevolution.NewYork:Harper,1952. 19Course,RonaldHarry.TheProblemofSocialCost.1960 20Cooper,PhillipJ.PublicLawandPublicAdministration.EnglewoodCliffs,N.J.:PrenticeHall,1988. 21Cooper,PhillipJ.”ConflictofConstructiveTension:TheChangingRelationshipofJudgesandAdministrators”PublicAdministrationReview45.November1985. 22Dahl,RobertA.TheScienceofPublicAdministration:ThreeProblems.PublicAdministrationReview.1947. 23DeglerCN.OutofOurPast:TheForcesthatShapedModemAmerica.NewYork:Harper,1959. 24Dimock,MarshallE.LawandDynamicAdministration.NewYork:Praeger,1980 25Donahue,JohnM.ThePrivatizationDecision:PublicEnds,PrivateMeans.NewYork:BasicBooks,1989. 26Downs,Anthony.AnEconomicTheoryofDemocracy.NewYork:Harper&Row,1957. 27Downs,Anthony.InsideBureaucracy.Boston:Little,Brown&Co.,1967. 28EastJP.CouncilManagerGovernment:ThePoliticalThoughtofitsFounder,RichardS.Childs.ChapelHill,NC:UniversityofNorthCarolinaPress,1965. 29Fayol,Henri.GeneralandIndustrialManagement.NewYork:PitmanPublishingCorporation,1949. 30Fleishman,Joel.Liebman,Lance&Moore,MarkH.TheMoralObligationsofGovernmentOfficialsCambridge,Mass.:HarvardUniversityPress,1981. 31Follett,MaryP.TheGivingofOrders.1926.Shafritz,JayM.&Hyde,AlbertCed.ClassicsofPublicAdministration4thed.pp53-60. 32Frederickson,H.George.NeighborhoodControlinthe1970s.NewYork:Chander,1973. 33_NewPublicAdministration.University,AL:TheUniversityofAlabamaPress,1980. 34French,Peter.EthicsinGovernment.EnglewoodCliffs,N.J.:PrenticeHall,1983. 35Golembiewski,Robert.Gibson,Frank&Cornog,GeoffreyY.PublicAdministration:ReadingsinInstitutionsProcesses,Behavior,Policy.Chicago:RandMcNally&Co.,1966. 36Goodnow,FJ.PoliticsandAdministration.NewYork:Macmillan,1900 37Goodsell,CT.TheGraceCommission:seekingefficiencyforthewholepeople.PublicAdministrationReview44:196-204,1984. 38Gulick,Luther.NotesontheTheoryofOrganization1937.SeeShafritz,JayM.&Hyde,AlbertCed.ClassicsofPublicAdministration4thed.pp81-89. 39HaberS.EfficiencyandUplift:ScientificManagementintheProgressiveEra,1820-1920.Chicago:UniversityofChicagoPress,1964. 40Herring,E.Pendleton.PublicAdministrationandPublicInterest.NewYork:McGrawHill,1937. 41HofstadterR.TheAgeofReform:FromBryanttoF.D.R.NewYork:AlfredA.Knopf,1955. 42Holzer,Marc&Gabrielian,Vatche.”FiveGreatIdeasinAmericanPublicAdministration”SeeHandbookofPublicAdministration2nded.EditedByRabin,J.Hildreth&Miller,GJ.1998 43Holzer,Marc.ProductivityandQualityManagement.SeeShafritz,JayM.&Hyde,AlbertCed.ClassicsofPublicAdministration4thed.pp558-566. 44HoogenboomA.OutlawingtheSpoils:AHistoryoftheCivilServiceReformMovement.Urbana:UniversityofIllinoispress,1961. 45Ingraham,Patricia.TheFoundationofMerit:PublicsServicesinAmericanDemocracy.Baltimore:JohnsHopkinsUniversityPress,1995. 46IngrahamPw,BarrilleuaxC.Motivatinggovernmentmagagersforretrenchment:somepossiblelessonsfromtheseniorexecutiveservice.PublicAdministrationReview43:393-402,1983. 47Kaufman,Herbert.AdministrationDecentralizationandpoliticalPower.1969. 48Key,V.O.,Politics,Parties,andPressuregroups,5thed.NewYork:Growell,1964. 49Koontz,H.,TheManagementtheoryjungle.JAcadManage4(3):1961 50Krislov,Samuel.RepresentativeBureaucracy.Minneapolis:UniversityofMinnesotaPress.1974. 51Levine,CharlesB.”O(jiān)rganizationalDeclineandCutbackManagement”PublicAdministrationReview.1978 52Light,PaulC.TheTidesofReform:MakingGovernmentWork,1945-1995.YaleUniversityPress:NewHavenandLondon.1997. 53Lilienthal,DavidE.TVA:DemocracyontheMarch.Newyork:HarperandRow,1944. 54Lindblom,CharlesE.TheScienceofMuddlingThrough.PublicAdministrationReview1959. 55Lipsky,Michael.Street-LevelBureaucracy.NewYork:RussellSageFoundation,1980. 56Lowi,TheodoreJ.TheEndofLiberalism:Ideology,PolicyandtheCrisisofPublicAuthority.NewYork:W.W.Norton&Co.,1969. 57Marini,Frank.TowardaNewPublicAdministration:MinnowbrookPerspective.Scranton,PA:ChandlerPublishingCo.,1971. 58Maslow,AbrahamH.APrefacetoMotivationTheory,PsychosomaticMed.5.1943. 59McCurdy,HE.PublicAdministration:ABiobliography.Washington,D.C.:AmericanUniversity,SchoolofGovernmentandPublicAdministration,1972,2d.Ed.,1986 60McCregor,Douglas.TheHumanSideofEnterprise.1957.SeeShafritz,JayM.&Hyde,AlbertCed.ClassicsofPublicAdministration4thed.pp192-197. 61Meriam,Lewis.ReorganizationoftheNationalGovernment:Whatdoesitinvolves.1939 62Moe,Ronald.ExploringtheLimitsofPrivatization.PublicAdministrationReview.1987. 63Mosher,FrederickC.Watergate:ImplicationsforResponsibleGovernment.NewYork:BasicBooks,1974. 64Nigro,FelixA.&Nigro,LloydG.ModernPublicAdministration.NewYork:HarperandRow,1973. 65Niskanen,William.BureaucracyandRepresentativeGovernment.Chicago:AldinePublishingCo.,1971. 66NPR.FromRedTapetoResults:GreatingaGovernmentThatWorksBetterandCostsLess,ReportoftheNationalPerformanceReview.Washington,D.C.:U.S.GovernmentPrintingOffice,September1993. 67Oates,Wallece.FiscalFederalism.Harcourt,1972. 68Olson,Mancur,Jr.,TheLogicofCollectiveAction:PublicGoodsandtheTheoryofGroups.Cambridge:HarvardUniversiytPress,1965. 69Osborne,David&Gaebler,Ted.ReinventingGovernment:HowtheEntrepreneurialSpiritisTransformingthePublicSector.Reading,Mass.:addisonWesleyPublishers,1992. 70PressmanJeffrey&Wiladvsky,Aaron.Implementation.Berkeley:UniversityofCaliforniaPress,1973 71RiordonWL.PlunkittofTammanyHall:ASeriesofVeryPlainTalksonVeryPracticalPolitics,DeliveredbyEx-SenatorGeorgeWashingtonPlunkitt,TheTammanyPhilosopher,fromHisRostrum,TheNewYorkCountyCourt-HouseBootblackStand.NewYork:AlfredA.Knopf,1948. 72Rivlin,Alice.SystematicThinkingforSocialAction.Washington,D.C.:BrookingsInstitution,1971. 73Rohr,JohnA.ToRunAConstitution:TheLegitimacyoftheAdministrativeState.Lawrence,KS:UniversityPressofKansas,1986. 74Rohr,JohnA.EthicsforBureaucrats.2d.edNewYork:MarcalDekker,1988. 75Rosenbloom,David.”PublicAdministrationTheoryandtheSeparationofPowers”PublicAdministrationReview.1983 76Rosenbloom,David.PublicAdministration:UnderstandingManagementPolitics,andLawinthePublicSector.NewYork:RandomHouse,1986.2ded.,1990. 77Rourke,FrancisE.Bureaucracy,Politics,andPublicPolicy.PublishedbyLittleBrown&Company(Canada)limited,2d.Ed.1976. 78Savas,ES.PrivatizingthePublicSector.Chatham,NJ:ChathamHouse,1982. 79Sava,E.E.Privatization:TheKeytoBetterGovernment.Chatham,N.J.:ChathamHouse,1987. 80Schick,Alan.CongressandMoney:Budgeting,Spending,andTaxing.WashingtonD.C.:UrbanInstitute,1980. 81Schick,Alan.”IncrementalBudgetinginaDecrementalAge”PolicyScience16Sept1983:1-25 82Selznick;Philip.TVAandtheGrassRoots,NewYork:Harper&Row,1949. 83Shafritz,J.M.&Hyde,A.C.ClassicsofPublicAdministration.HarcourtBraceCollegePublishers1997. 84Simon,Herbert.TheProverbsofAdministration1946.SeeShafritz,JayM.&Hyde,AlbertCed.ClassicsofPublicAdministration4thed.pp127-141. 85Simon,HerbertA.AdministrativeBehavior.NewYork:TheFreePress,1947. 86Stivers,Camilla.GenderImagesinPublicAdministration:LegitimacyandtheAdministrativeState.NewburyPark:Sage,1993 87StillmanRJII.TheRiseoftheCityManager,Albuquerque,NM:UniversityofNewMexicoPress,1974. 88SuchmanEdward.EvaluativeResearch.NewYork:RussellSageFoundation,1967 89Thompson,DennisF.PoliticalEthicsandPublicOffice.Cambridge,Mass.:HarvardUniversityPress,1987 90_.ThePossibilityofAdministrativeEthics.PublicAdministrationReview.1985. 91Taylor,FrederickW.ShopManagement.NewYork:HarperandRow,1903. 92_.ThePrinciplesofScientificManagement.NewYork:W.W.Norton,1911. 93_.ScientificManagement.NewYork:HarperandRow,1923. 94Uveges&Keller,”O(jiān)nehundredYearsofAmericanPublicAdministrationandCounting:MovingintoaSecondCenturyintheStudyandPracticeofPublicManagementinAmericanLife”1998.SeeHandbookofPublicAdministration2nded.EditedByRabin,J.Hildreth&Miller,GJ.1998 95Riper,Van.HistoryoftheUnitedStatesCivilService,Evanston,IL:Row,Peterson,1958. 96Riper,Van.TheAmericanAdministrativestate:Wilsonandthefounders-anunorthodoxview.PublicAdministrationRaview43:477-490,1983. 97Weber,Max.Bureaucracy1922.Shafritz,JayM.&Hyde,AlbertCed.ClassicsofPublicAdministration4thed.pp37-43. 98WilloughbyWF.TheMovementforBudgetaryReformintheStatesShafritz,JayM.&Hyde,AlbertCed.ClassicsofPublicAdministration4thed.pp33-36. 99Waldo,DwightAdministrativeState.NewYork:TheRonaldPress,1948. 100Waldo,Dwight.PublicAdministrationinaTimeofTurbulence 101Weiss,CarolH.EvaluationResearch:MethodsforAssessingProgramEffectiveness.EnglewoodCliffs,N.J.:Prentice-Hall,1972. 102White,Joseph&Wildavsky,Aaron.TheDeficitandthePublicInterest:TheSearchforResponsibleBudgetinginthe1980s.1989. 103WhiteLDIntroductiontotheStudyofPublicadministration.NewYork:MacMillan,1926. 104_.TheCityManager.Chicago:UniversityofChicagoPress,1927. 105Wholey,Joseph.FederalEvaluationPolicy.WashingtonD.C.:UrbanInstitute,1970. 106Wildavsky,Aaron.ThePoliticsoftheBudgetaryProcess,4thed.Boston:Little,Brown,1964,1984. 107Wildavsky,Aaron.RescuingPolicyAnalysisfromPPBS.PublicAdministrationReview.1969 108Wildavsky,Aaron.HowtolimitGovernmentSpending.Berkeley:UniversityofCaliforniaPressandRussellSageFoundation,1980. 109Wildavsky,Aaron.TheNewPoliticsoftheBudgetaryProcess.Boston:Little,Brown,1988. 110Wilson,ThomasWoodrow.TheStudyofAdministration.PoliticssciQ2:197-222,1887.13